MOSt Shares M50 – Is it another offer in the crowd?

Recently SEBI’s Chairman C B Bhave commented if 3000 schemes flooded in the industry served a purpose to investors’ fraternity as they have failed to convince the investors of the long-term benefits of their products. He also suggested that the mutual funds should provide better returns by rolling out simpler products. Now coming to another zone where Mutual Funds continue to roll out new NFOs – HDFC Gold ETF, Peerless Income Plus Fund, MOSt Shares M50 ETF, Taurus MIP Advantage, Benchmark Short Term, Axis Triple Advantage and many Fixed Maturity Plans (FMPs). I have been wondering if I am an investor which one I should choose. As a simple investor, my aim should be to maximize returns with least volatility; also I should bear minimal costs.


Among the above captioned NFOs, all the NFOs were more or less similar to the existing plans offered by another fund houses; I found a unique offer by Motilal Oswal AMC with its maiden NFO MOSt Shares M50 ETF. Though the ETF concept is new in India and has not been well received by investors yet, ETFs are on high. Historically, it has grown exceptionally even in intermittent market. Let me give out in detail why MOSt Shares M50 ETF is unique and investors’ friendly.

Product Features

As claimed by Motilal Oswal Mutual Fund, MOSt Shares M50 ETF is India’s 1st fundamentally weighted ETF based on the S&P CNX Index (Nifty). Logically, it is the remixed version of Nifty 50. The fund house has created its own basket “MOSt 50 Basket”, intellectually owned by MOAMC and managed by India Index Services & Products Ltd. (IISL). The weights of stocks in MOSt 50 Basket will be decided by their pre-defined methodology based on stock’s fundamentals (ROE, Net Worth, Retained Earnings and Valuation).

The fund aims to generate investment returns with minimal costs and active investment style. With no entry and exit load, the investors get another opportunity in terms of liquidity. The fund manager will invest 95-100% of the money in MOSt 50 basket and the exposure to fixed income and money market instruments along with cash call will be restricted to 0-5% of the total money invested.

Investment Strategy

The fund has reworked the weights of stocks in Nifty based on its own defined fundamentals such as Return on Equity, Net Worth, Retained Earnings and Price. They have designed the capital allocation strategy of the MOSt 50 basket to reduce the risk associated with price volatility of individual constituents. The table 1 defines the basket classification of MOSt 50 Basket.

So, some of the companies will be more dominant than others based on the current methodology.

Back Testing

The fund has done the back-testing with current methodology for the last 3-year period and the portfolio has given an additional alpha (excess of returns over its benchmark, in simple terms) of 13.2 per cent. It has also beta value of 0.94 against Nifty beta of 1.

Should you buy?

As far as the ETF story is going on, it has been building up in India. People have started recognizing the importance of ETFs as fund managers have failed to outperform the benchmarks over a longer period. Moreover, this new ETFs, also called as active ETF scored over others and provide uniqueness in terms of simplicity and maximization of returns over a longer period.