RBI’s Policymaking – Is the transmission happening?

Post Lehman Crisis, the world scenario changed drastically forcing many nations to follow the accommodative measures so as to ease the liquidity deficit in the financial system. India, too, remained coupled to global events and remained unscathed from a global slowdown because of its increased integration with the global economy.

In India, the Central Bank, Reserve Bank of India took a series of accommodative measures to support the economy. Soon, the world scenario changed with confidence winning and improved numbers. However, the ease of liquidity put pressure on pricing which led to burgeoning of inflation. In real practice, India’s economy gets driven by two factors – first, domestic consumption story which, in recent years, improved on account of increased purchasing power due to various government sponsored initiatives and other factors and second, direct government aids to different sectors/industries in the form of duty cuts or other aids. The multiple factors also put pressure on inflation which also got imported, thanks to high commodity prices including crude oil, to a certain extent due to our large dependency on them.

Also, read – FIIs’ rave party in India; Economic indicators are at loggerheads

In series of steps, the RBI hiked policy rates ten times successively, effectively by a total of 425 points since Mar 2010 in order to tame inflation which had been due to structural reasons too. Every time, RBI raises policy rates, it remains firm in taming the inflation which has become a toy of political storm too.

To support the fast transmission of policymaking, the central bank also made some changes in policy decisions – (1) introduction of base rate (2) the new Marginal Standing Facility (MSF) to support additional lending (3) restrictions on cross-lending between banks and mutual funds which have been rampant till some time ago. However, the RBI expressed its annoyance over the quality of data on which they have been operating the monetary policy. No doubt, the transmission of monetary policy has improved and to a large extent, the hiking of rates have slowed down the demand and also affected the economy growth, thanks to increased interest rates which have raised the average cost of capital. It has affected the capex investment too. In recent times, the RBI questioned the quality of data on Index of Industrial Production (IIP) which measures the industrial growth and Wholesale Price Index (WPI) which is also called as Headline Inflation; these data do not reflect the real economic activity. Volatility still persists in IIP and WPI. Even the recent improvements in IIP and WPI as per 2004-05 series have not helped the central bank; the data get revised by a wider spread on subsequent months. As evident, even the 10 rate hikes, one after another in the past 15 months have not dampened the demand effectively. In the last 2 years, economic forecasts from all government institutions, from Central Statistical Organisation (CSO) to RBI to Planning Commission have been questioned as they turned inaccurate. The high fiscal deficit and continuous gilt supply also kept RBI at bay in effective transmission of monetary policy.

Also, read – Price Hikes – Are we really ready?

Does it say RBI has failed?

Not really! In the past, RBI had been instrumental in taking the country out of the century worst financial crisis; so, it won’t be good to comment on their effectiveness. Their hands are also tied in terms of data availability, political interference (though it is said that RBI is not under the government interference but not in real sense) and dynamic nature of the situation. The various structural issues including supply-related factors also waned the effectiveness of policy transmission. The persistently high food inflation in the last two years has migrated to manufacturing inflation too.

The RBI says that they are handicapped by the reliability of some of the basic data that they need to use in policy calculations which remains true to a large extent. In a nut-shell, India’s inflation must drop before it eats the economy; hope the government must be listening to improve the effectiveness of policy making which are indirectly linked to them.

Happy Reading!

-          Amar Ranu

RBI 3rd Quarter Monetary Policy Review 2010-11 – Containing inflation to remain predominant objective

The RBI monetary policy soap opera verdict is out. The mixed global recoveries rather still subdued and the inflationary pressures in emerging market economies (EMEs) including India has been on the top of the radar of RBI in its Third Quarter Monetary Policy Review 2010-11. From the earlier stance of growth-inflation dynamics, the RBI moved to anchor the inflationary expectations likely due to sharp increase in the prices of primary food articles and the recent spurt in global oil prices.

Key Policy Measures:

•  Repo rate, the rate at which banks borrow from RBI, up by 25 bps at 6.5 per cent
•  Reverse repo rate, the rate at which the RBI lends to banks, up by 25 bps at 5.5 per cent
•  Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR), the portion of deposit that banks keep with the central bank retained at 6.0 per cent
• The inflation target revised upwards to 7 per cent from 5.5 per cent for march-end 2011
• The baseline projection of real GDP growth retained at 8.5 per cent with an upward bias.

Domestic Outlook

The domestic economy is on strong trajectory path as revealed by the 8.9 per cent GDP growth in the first half of 2010-11 powered mainly by domestic factors including strong consumption. The strong agricultural output on satisfactory kharif production and higher rabi sowing will contribute significantly to overall GDP growth in 2010-11. The industrial output also showed buoyant figures; however, the significant volatility adds uncertainty to the outlook.

Inflationary Concerns

The headline inflation as measured by WPI remained uncomfortably high since Jan 2010. Although it moderated between Aug and Nov 2010, it reversed in Dec 2010 mainly due to sharp increase in prices of vegetables specially onion, tomatoes, garlic etc and petrol prices. The current inflation level is also contributed by structural demand-supply mismatches in other cereal items. Considering all the scenarios, the baseline projection of WPI inflation for March 2011 has been revised upwards to 7 per cent from 5.5 per cent earlier. The sources of price pressure – fuel and non-fuel commodity prices and some food items could be non-responsive to RBI monetary policy actions. Going forward, the price level will depend how the global and domestic prices evolve.

Liquidity – still in deficit mode

Since the outflows caused due to 3G and WIMAX payments, the liquidity remained in deficit mode in the financial system. Also, the sluggish deposit growth, far below the RBI projection along with the non-food credit growth of 24.4 per cent worsened the liquidity in the system. Meanwhile, the RBI also intervened by cutting SLR by 1 per cent and initiated OMO transactions worth Rs. 67,000 crore. The additional liquidity support to banks up to 1 per cent of NDTL has been extended up to April 08, 2011. Under this, the bank may seek waiver of penal interest purely as an ad hoc measure. The 2^nd LAF will be conducted on a daily basis up to April 08, 2011.

Burgeoning CAD (Current Account Deficits)

The current CAD expected to be around 3.5 per cent of GDP is not sustainable as feared by RBI. CAD, an outcome of net exports and imports may get worsened further if the global recovery improves. Till now, the capital flows, which so far have been broadly sufficient to finance CAD may get adversely affected as the global recovery can trigger the flight to safety.

Global Scenario

There has been a significant improvement in global growth prospects in recent weeks; however, the recoveries are still fragile with uneven scenarios in Euro region and Japan. The deflation fears looming largely on advanced economies got some reprieve with early signs of inflation. The real GDP growth in the US improved to 2.6 per cent in Q3 2010-11 after witnessing a muted growth in 1.7 per cent. The retail sales and corporate capital spending has improved. Unlike in advanced economies, Emerging Market Economies (EME) has been affected by burgeoning inflation trends due to spurt in global food prices including a spurt in crude oil. 

With better signs of sustainable recoveries, the global growth in 2010-11 is anticipated to be less frictional and will show firm signs of sustainable recoveries. With rising prices on increased demand, inflation would be a global concern in 2011.

Why the rate hikes?

The market had been anticipating a tougher stand from RBI as the inflationary issues failed to settle down. While the market had mixed anticipations – 25bps vs 50bps hike, the RBI followed a calibrated approach – hiking the policy rates by 25 bps only – after taking a “comma” stand for few weeks in its policy rate hikes. The current policy rate is still below the pre-crisis level. Since March 2010, it has increased rates by six times. Also, keeping the LAF corridor at 1 per cent, the RBI intended to bring down the volatility in overnight rates within the corridor.

Happy Reading!

-          Amar Ranu

Fiscal Deficits at sub-5.5 per cent vs Higher Borrowing – which one to stick with?

Too many cooks spoil the broth! Rightly said... Post the global financial crisis, many countries – developed and emerging economies went for expansionary monetary and fiscal policies to revive their slowing economy. In India too, the slowdown of economy forced the Central Bank, the RBI and Central Government to announce a series of monetary and fiscal policies which shook the Indian Government’s finances. Three major expenses like provision for Sixth Pay Commission, Loan Waiver and MGNREGA (Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Program) and various other subsidies including policy rate cuts led to significant intensification of the India’s Fiscal Deficit.

These unplanned expenditures in terms of loose policies and subsidies have badly affected the fiscal deficits. For Fiscal Year 2010-11, the Central Government fiscal deficit and combined gross fiscal deficit have been pegged at 8.2 per cent. However, there is an apprehension that it can shoot up further. In FY 2009-10, the fiscal deficit was 6.8 per cent of GDP. For FY 2011-12, it has been projected to bring it down to 4.4 per cent.

So, what happens if the fiscal deficit shoots up?

It means that the government will borrow extra to finance their planned and unplanned expenditures. If the government borrows extra for its spending, the level of money supplies rises which may compel to print more money, thus, leading to a hike in inflation rate. 

Current Scenario

With the improvement in economic conditions, the RBI has rolled back many of its accommodative measures introduced in year starting from 2008-09 bringing the policy rates to pre-crisis level. The net borrowing of Rs. 3.81 lakh crore will be executed smoothly except at few occasions where it has been devolved to PDs. However, the 3G and WIMAX auctions which collected worth Rs. 75,000 crore created the liquidity fissures which became a daily headache for RBI. In many occasions, the RBI has reiterated its comfort in repo borrowing up to 1 per cent of Net Demand and Time Liabilities (NDTL). However, the borrowing has been in range of over 2 per cent of NDTL which prompted the RBI to cut the SLR to 24 per cent and also introduced bond repurchase worth Rs. 48,000 crore under OMOs in four tranches.

The tight liquidity scenario was contemplating that the government may go for cancellation of some of its regular weekly borrowing as it has some unspent revenues lying with them. However, the Finance Ministry found support after the Nominal GDP data was released which rose on high inflation and on account of new series in headline inflation as measured by WPI. The nominal GDP
which expanded 19.8 per cent in the first half of the fiscal year 2010-11 provides the room for additional borrowing if the growth rate is intact in the 2^nd fiscal and the budgeted borrowing would amount to 5 per cent of the GDP only. The nominal GDP figures have risen due to burgeoning high
inflation rates which have been in double for most part of years and a new inflation index i.e. 2004-05. 

View

Since the fiscal numbers are calculated in current prices and if the government sticks to the number plan, it may have an additional room to borrow. The 5.5 per cent budgeted Fiscal Deficit of the GDP was thought of on account of assumption of 12.5 per cent growth in nominal GDP. However, it has grown at 19.8 per cent in the first half of the FY 2010-11; so the government may announce in reduction of Fiscal Deficit number at sub-5.5 per cent or may go for additional borrowing.

Given the tight liquidity scenario, it is unlikely that they will go for additional borrowing.  However, the quantum of OMOs done totaling Rs. 41,266 crore (in four tranches) may give a reason to borrow again beyond the budgeted specified limit if the liquidity improves in the financial system so as to finance its social schemes. After all, the election preparation is on!

Happy Reading!       - Amar Ranu

RBI Mid-Sept Monetary Policy Review – Loans to become dearer

The hawkish global economy recovery coupled with high inflationary pressures forced the Central Bank to raise Policy Rates at the pace faster than the market expectations. The Central Bank, RBI in its Mid-Quarter Monetary Policy Review increased the repo rate and reverse repo rate under LAF.


• Repo Rate and Reverse Repo Rate under Liquidity Adjustment Facility (LAF) increased by 25 bps and 50 bps to 6 per cent and 5 per cent respectively, thus, bringing out the LAF rate corridor to 1 per cent.
• Bank Rate and CRR (Cash Reserve Ration) retained at the same level of 6 per cent each

Domestic Scenario
The RBI stressed on that fact that Inflation has become a kind of concern; even the new index of headline inflation as measured by WPI suggests that the monthly average of WPI inflation for Q1 of 2010-11 under the new series at 10.6 per cent was about 50 bps lower than the rate of 11.1 per cent under the old series. Inflation rates have reached its peak and are most likely to remain at the same level for the next few months. However, Food Inflation continues to move northwards and touched 14 per cent in Aug 2010 as per new series.

Another concern that the RBI documented that the negative real interest rates have been affecting deposit growth rates of banks as savers look for higher returns elsewhere. The RBI wanted deposit growth rates to increase as accordingly the bond supply will be a thorough affair in its weekly auctions without any devolvement which may put pressure on yields. The trend suggests that higher deposit growth rate require higher demands for federal bonds as the bank need to maintain the SLR requirement.

The RBI also indicated that higher than expected realizations on 3G and BMA auctions combined with robust tax revenues have virtually eliminated the risk of the fiscal deficit overshooting its target of 5.5 per cent, even after the additional demand for grants from the Central Government have come up in the Parliament. The Water God, Monsoon has revived the growth prospects in Agriculture which will contribute to good rabi harvest.

Liquidity – from a large surplus to deficit
From a surplus mode, the liquidity entered into a deficit mode after the July Policy review, thus, making the repo rate as the operative policy rate. The current hike will prompt many banks to raise the lending and deposit rates which will sustain the strength of the transmission mechanism.

Global Factors
The RBI remained elusive of global circumstances where the slow recovery has halted many advanced economies to hold their rates further for an extended period. This led to massive inflows into developing economies including India. Moreover, the weak global demand coupled with strong domestic demand has increased the trade deficit and the current account deficit has also been widening. However, Europe has demonstrated remarkable resilience; China too bounced back with industrial production and trade numbers reviving sharply. “Overall, even as the global environment continues to be a cause for caution, the big picture has not worsened significantly since July”, said RBI in a press note.

Need for the hike in Policy Rates
Though the hike in policy rates were expected but by increasing the Reverse Repo Rate by 50 bps, higher than the market expectation of 25 bps, the RBI has used this opportunity to reduce the LAF rate corridor, which will reduce the expected volatility in overnight rates. Moreover, it also wanted to reduce the impact of negative real interest rates which led to savers to move to alternate products giving higher returns.

Yields to fall – Focus on Income Funds

Inflation has started coming down. WPI, the official figure for measure of Inflation came down to 9.97 per cent, 0.03 per cent shy of two digits. The RBI concern on ballooned inflation, a shift of focus from growth to inflation led to a series of monetary policy measures this year, already four times witnessed. More worrisome is the fact that the inflation is no longer food prices driven; in fact it has become more generalized. Non-food inflation has risen from almost zero level in Nov 2009 to 10.9 per cent in June 2010, contribution 70 per cent to inflation.
The bond yields rose abruptly in India, however, the bond yields came down globally. For the first time in its history, the 10-year Indian and US bond yields are facing a divergent state.

The G-Sec markets witnessed hardening of yields in July and Aug 2010. The 10-year G-Sec Bond and Short Term Bonds’ yields have spiked in the recent past; which we believe that they may go up further projected the advance tax outflows in Mid September. The short term yields (1-year CD and CP) have already spiked by 200 bps in the last 3 months. The benchmark bond 7.80 per cent 2020 has already touched 8.08 per cent, currently hovering at 8.03%. It touched its four months high since May 2010. The RBI is still not comfortable with the inflation figures and the market opines that it may go with further rate hikes in the upcoming Monetary Policy meet due in mid-Sept.
We believe that the G-Sec yields in long term will follow its logical course of softening. The reasons are:
• Softening of inflation in coming months
• Improvement in Government revenues in the form of improved tax inflows, 3G and WIMAX auctions
• Reduction in fiscal deficit, if the excess revenue is used efficiently
• Spread in the Repo rate and 10-year G-Sec rate (already at multiple year high) should reduce
• Liquidity is bound to improve; temporarily we might witness liquidity deficiency in the system
• For the first time since 2002, interest rates in India are divergent to US yields (Check the above table)

Since US government continues to follow an expansionary monetary policy to revive growth, the Fed has kept its interest rates abysmal low for another extended period. However, in India, RBI has shifted its focus from good GDP/IIP growth to inflation management; therefore, we witnessed tightening of monetary policy. When inflation comes under control over next few months, bond yields (long dated bonds) will follow its logical course of softening. For those seeking to ride the yield curve at the longer end which could potentially ease in the 2nd half, we would recommend allocations to Income Fund having high average maturity. In the above stated scenario, the income funds stand to benefit with a time horizon of 12 to 18 months.